Where the Underlying is or relates to one or more funds the relevant Financial Instruments reflect the performance of such funds, which may be “hedge funds”.
A hedge fund may trade and invest in a broad range of investment interests such as debt and equity securities, commodities and foreign exchange and may enter into derivative transactions, including, without limitation, futures and options. A hedge fund may often be illiquid and may only be traded on a monthly, quarterly or even less frequent basis. For all these reasons and those described below, investing directly or indirectly in hedge funds is generally considered to be risky.
If the Underlying is a hedge fund which does not perform sufficiently, its value will fall, possibly to zero. The hedge fund(s) reflected in the relevant Underlying from time to time and its/their hedge fund trading advisors, as well as the markets and instruments in which they invest, are often not subject to review by governmental authorities, self-regulatory organization’s or other supervisory authorities.
The following is a non-exhaustive list of the risks associated with investing in hedge funds:
(a) Investment Manager
The performance of a hedge fund will depend on the performance of the investments selected by key individuals associated with the day-to-day operations of the investment manager of the relevant hedge fund and upon the expertise of such key individuals. Any withdrawal or other cessation of investment activities on behalf of the investment manager by any of these individuals could result in losses and/or the termination or the dissolution of the relevant hedge fund.
The investment strategy, investment restrictions and investment objectives of a hedge fund give its investment manager considerable discretion to invest the assets thereof and there can be no guarantee that the investment manager’s investment decisions will be profitable or will effectively hedge against the risk of market or other conditions and thus such decisions may cause the value of the relevant hedge fund to decline.
An investment manager may receive performance related fees, which may be substantial. The manner of calculating such fees may create an incentive for the investment manager to make investments that are riskier or more speculative than would be the case if such fees were not paid to the investment manager.
In addition, since the performance fees may be calculated on a basis that includes both unrealised and realised gains on the relevant hedge fund’s assets, such fees may be greater than if they were based solely on realised gains. If a hedge fund does not perform or does not perform sufficiently to cover the fees, the value of the relevant hedge fund will fall and may fall to zero.
(b) Lack of segregation of assets
A prime broker may be, or may have been, appointed in relation to a hedge fund and will accordingly be responsible for custody, clearing, financing and reporting services with respect to the securities transactions entered into by the relevant investment manager. This may result in the hedge fund’s assets being rehypothecated, pooled or placed in an omnibus account. In such cases the hedge fund’s assets may not be segregated from those of the prime broker’s other clients, the prime broker itself or third party sub-custodians.
Please see the section entitled “Considerations Relating to Use of Prime Brokerage Arrangements” for further information on the risks that hedge funds may face when using prime brokerage arrangements.
(c) Hedging risks
An investment manager may utilise warrants, futures, forward contracts, swaps, options and other derivative instruments involving securities, currencies, interest rates, commodities and other asset categories (and combinations of the foregoing) for the purposes of establishing “market neutral” arbitrage positions as part of its trading strategies and to hedge against movements in the capital markets.
Hedging against a decline in the value of a portfolio position does not eliminate fluctuations in the values of portfolio positions or prevent losses if the values of such positions decline, but establishes other positions designed to gain from those same developments, thus moderating the decline in the portfolio positions’ value.
Such hedging transactions may also limit the opportunity for gain if the value of the portfolio position should increase. Moreover, it may not always be possible for the investment manager to execute hedging transactions, or to do so at prices, rates or levels advantageous to the hedge fund. The success of any hedging transactions will be subject to the movements in the direction of securities prices and currency and interest rates, and stability or predictability of pricing relationships.
Therefore, while a hedge fund might enter into such transactions to reduce currency exchange rate and interest rate risks, unanticipated changes in currency or interest rates may result in poorer overall performance for the hedge fund than if it had not engaged in any such hedging transactions.
In addition, the degree of correlation between price movements of the instruments used in a hedging strategy and price movements in the portfolio position being hedged may vary. Moreover, for a variety of reasons, the investment manager may not be able to, or may not seek to, establish a perfect correlation between such hedging instruments and the portfolio holdings being hedged. An imperfect correlation may prevent a hedge fund from achieving the intended hedge or expose a hedge fund to risk of loss.
(d) Leverage
Hedge funds may be able to borrow (or employ leverage) without limitation and may utilize various lines of credit and other forms of leverage, including swaps and repurchase agreements. While leverage presents opportunities for increasing a hedge fund’s total return, it has the effect of potentially increasing losses as well. If income and appreciation on investments made with borrowed funds are less than the required interest payments on the borrowings, the value of the hedge fund will decrease.
Additionally, any event which adversely affects the value of an investment by a hedge fund would be magnified to the extent such hedge fund is leveraged. The cumulative effect of the use of leverage by a hedge fund in a market that moves adversely to such hedge fund’s investments could result in a substantial loss to the hedge fund that would be greater than if the hedge fund were not leveraged.
Furthermore, any use by the hedge fund of swaps and other derivatives to gain exposure to certain investments may leverage the hedge fund’s assets, and subject it to the risks described above.
(e) Risks associated with the use of margin borrowings
An investment manager’s anticipated use of short-term margin borrowings will result in certain additional risks to the relevant hedge fund. For example, if securities pledged to brokers to secure a hedge fund’s margin accounts decline in value, such hedge fund could be subject to a “margin call”, pursuant to which it must either deposit additional funds with the broker or be the subject of mandatory liquidation of the pledged securities to compensate for the decline in value.
In the event of a sudden drop in the value of the hedge fund’s assets, the investment manager might not be able to liquidate assets quickly enough to pay off the margin debt.
In such a case, the relevant prime broker may liquidate additional assets of the hedge fund, in its sole discretion, in order to satisfy such margin debt. The premiums for certain options traded on non-US exchanges may be paid for on margin. If the investment manager sells an option on a futures contract, it may be required to deposit margin in an amount equal to the margin requirement established for the futures contract underlying the option and, in addition, an amount substantially equal to the premium for the option.
The margin requirements imposed on the writing of options, although adjusted to reflect the probability that out-of-the-money options will not be exercised, can in fact be higher than those imposed in dealing in the futures markets directly. Whether any margin deposit will be required for over-the-counter options will depend on the agreement of the parties to the transaction.
(f) Low credit quality and distressed securities
Hedge funds may invest in securities linked to particularly risky investments or to securities of issuers in weak financial condition, experiencing poor operating results, having substantial capital needs or negative net worth, facing special competitive or product obsolescence problems, or that are involved in bankruptcy or reorganization proceedings.
Investments of this type may involve substantial risks that can result in substantial or, at times, even total losses. Some of the risks inherent in investments in such entities are described in “Financial Instruments linked to low credit quality securities” and “Financial Instruments linked to distressed securities” .
(g) Derivatives
Hedge funds may invest in derivative instruments (some of which may be complex) which seek to modify or replicate the investment performance of particular securities, commodities, currencies, interest rates, indices or markets on a leveraged or unleveraged basis. These instruments generally have counterparty risk and are subject to the risks described in “Financial Instruments linked to Derivatives” above.
Hedge funds may also buy or sell options on a variety of underlying assets.
The risk of writing (selling) options is unlimited in that the writer of the option must purchase (in the case of a put) or sell (in the case of a call) the underlying security at a certain price upon exercise. There is no limit on the price a hedge fund may have to pay to meet its obligations as an option writer. As assets that can have no value at settlement, options can introduce a significant additional element of leverage and risk to a hedge fund’s market exposure.
The use of certain options strategies can subject a hedge fund to investment losses that are significant even in the context of positions for which the relevant investment manager has correctly anticipated the direction of market prices or price relationships.
(h) Special risks associated with trading in over-the-counter derivatives
Some of the markets in which a hedge fund may effect derivative transactions are “over-the-counter” or “interdealer” markets, which may be illiquid and are sometimes subject to larger spreads between the bid and offer prices than exchange-traded derivative transactions. The participants in such markets are typically not subject to credit evaluation and regulatory oversight, which would be the case with members of “exchange-based” markets. This exposes the hedge fund to the risk of counterparty default or a delay in settlement and thus the risks described in “Financial Instruments linked to Derivatives” above.
These factors may cause a hedge fund to suffer a loss due to adverse market movements while replacement transactions are executed or otherwise. Such “counterparty risk” is accentuated where the hedge fund has concentrated its transactions with a single or small group of counterparties. A hedge fund generally is not restricted from dealing with any particular counterparty or from concentrating any or all of its transactions with one counterparty.
In addition, if an investment manager engages in such over-the-counter transactions, the relevant hedge fund will be exposed to the risk that the counterparty (usually the relevant prime broker) will fail to perform its obligations under the transaction. The valuation of over-the-counter derivative transactions is also subject to greater uncertainty and variation than that of exchange-traded derivatives.
The “replacement” value of a derivative transaction may differ from the “liquidation” value of such transaction, and the valuation provided by a hedge fund’s counterparty to such transactions may differ from the valuation provided by a third party or the value upon liquidation of the transaction.
Under certain circumstances it may not be possible for a hedge fund to obtain market quotations for the value of an over-the-counter derivatives transaction.
A hedge fund may also be unable to close out or enter into an offsetting over-the-counter derivative transaction at a time it desires to do so, resulting in significant losses. In particular, the closing-out of an over-the-counter derivative transaction may usually only be effected with the consent of the counterparty to the transaction. If such consent is not obtained, a hedge fund will not be able to close out its obligations and may suffer losses.
(i) Illiquid investments
Hedge funds may make investments which are subject to legal or other restrictions on transfer or for which no liquid market exists, such as equity securities in private companies and are subject to the risks described in “Finance Instruments linked to private equity or illiquid assets and real estate” above.
In addition, futures positions taken by a hedge fund may become illiquid because, for example, certain commodity exchanges limit fluctuations in certain futures contract prices during a single day by regulations referred to as “daily price fluctuation limits” or “daily limits” as described in “Financial Instruments linked to Commodities and/or Commodity Futures” above.
(j) Legal and regulatory risks
Legal and regulatory changes could adversely affect a hedge fund. Regulation of investment vehicles, such as hedge funds and of many of the investments an investment manager is permitted to make on behalf of a hedge fund, is still evolving and therefore subject to change. In addition, many governmental agencies, self-regulatory organisations and exchanges are authorised to take extraordinary actions in the event of market emergencies. The effect of any future legal or regulatory change on a hedge fund is impossible to predict, but could be substantial and adverse.
(k) Short-selling
A hedge fund may use a short-selling strategy and therefore be subject to, inter alia, the risks described in the section entitled “Considerations Relating to Short-Selling”.
(l) Securities Financing Transactions
A hedge fund may authorise its prime broker to enter into securities financing transactions in relation to the securities which the prime broker holds on behalf of the hedge fund. The hedge fund may therefore be subject to, inter alia, the risks described in the section entitled “Considerations Relating to Securities Financing Transactions”.
(m) Commodities and Commodity futures
A hedge fund may invest in commodities and/or commodity futures and therefore be subject to, inter alia, the risks described in “Financial Instruments linked to Commodities and/or Commodity Futures”.
(n) Hedge fund compensation
A hedge fund typically provides for a performance fee or allocation, over and above a basic advisory fee, to its general partner, investment manager or person serving in an equivalent capacity. Performance fees or allocations could create an incentive for an investment manager to choose riskier or more speculative underlying investments than would otherwise be the case.
(o) “Soft Dollar” payments
In selecting brokers, banks and dealers to effect transactions on behalf a hedge fund, an investment manager may consider such factors as price, the ability of the brokers, banks and/or dealers to effect transactions promptly and reliably, their facilities, the operational efficiency with which transactions are effected, their financial strength, integrity and stability and the competitiveness of commission rates in comparison with other brokers, banks and dealers, as well as the quality, comprehensiveness and frequency of any products or services provided, or expenses paid, by such brokers, banks and dealers.
Products and services may include research items used by the investment manager in making investment decisions, and expenses so paid may include general overhead expenses of the investment manager. Such “soft dollar” benefits may cause an investment manager to execute a transaction with a specific broker, bank, or dealer even though it may not offer the lowest transaction fees. An investment manager is not required to
- (i) obtain the lowest brokerage commission rates or
- (ii) combine or arrange orders to obtain the lowest brokerage commission rates on its brokerage business.
If an investment manager determines that the amount of commissions charged by a broker is reasonable in relation to the value of the brokerage and research products or services provided by such broker, it may execute transactions for which such broker’s commissions are greater than the commissions another broker might charge.
Such brokerage commissions may be paid to brokers who execute transactions for the relevant managed account and which supply, pay for or rebate a portion of the hedge fund’s brokerage commissions to the hedge fund for payment of the cost of property or services (such as research services, telephone lines, news and quotation equipment, computer facilities and publications) utilized by the relevant investment manager or its affiliates.
An investment manager will have the option to use “soft dollars” generated by its investment activities to pay for the property and services described above. The term “soft dollars” refers to the receipt by an investment manager of property and services provided by brokers (or futures commission merchants in connection with futures transactions) without any cash payment by such investment manager based on the volume of revenues generated from brokerage commissions for transactions executed for clients of the investment manager.
An investment manager will consider the amount and nature of research services provided by brokers, as well as the extent to which such services are relied upon, and will attempt to allocate a portion of the brokerage business of the relevant managed account on the basis of those considerations.
(p) Special risks associated with trading in forward contracts
Hedge funds may engage in forward trading. Forward contracts, unlike futures contracts, are not traded on exchanges and are not standardised, rather, banks and dealers act as principals in these markets, negotiating each transaction on an individual basis. Forward and “cash” trading is substantially unregulated; there is no limitation on daily price movements and speculative position limits are not applicable.
The principals who deal in the forward markets are not required to continue to make markets in the currencies or commodities they trade and these markets can experience periods of illiquidity, sometimes of significant duration. There have been periods during which certain participants in these markets have been unable to quote prices for certain currencies or commodities or have quoted prices with an unusually wide spread between the price at which they were prepared to buy and that at which they were prepared to sell.
Disruptions can occur in any market traded by the hedge funds due to unusually high trading volume, political intervention or other factors. Market illiquidity or disruption could result in major losses to a hedge fund.
(q) Concentration of investments
Although in general a hedge fund will aim to invest in diversified investments, the investment manager in respect of a hedge fund may invest such hedge fund’s assets in a limited number of investments that may be concentrated in a few countries, industries, sectors of an economy and/or issuers.
As a result, although investments by hedge funds should be diversified, the negative impact on the value of the relevant hedge fund from adverse movements in a particular country, economy or industry or in the value of the securities of a particular issuer could be considerably greater than if such hedge fund were not permitted to concentrate its investments to such an extent.
(r) Turnover
Hedge funds may invest on the basis of certain short-term market considerations. As a result, the turnover rate within hedge funds is expected to be significant, potentially involving substantial brokerage commissions, fees and other transaction costs.
(s) Operational and human error
The success of a hedge fund depends in part upon the relevant investment manager’s accurate calculation of price relationships, the communication of precise trading instructions and ongoing position evaluations. In addition, an investment manager’s strategies may require active and ongoing management of durations and other variables, and dynamic adjustments to a hedge fund’s positions.
There is the possibility that, through human error, oversight or operational weaknesses, mistakes could occur in this process and lead to significant trading losses and an adverse effect on the net asset value of the relevant hedge fund.
(t) Reliability of valuations
Hedge funds are valued pursuant to the hedge fund’s instrument governing such valuations. The governing instruments of hedge funds generally provide that any securities or investments which are illiquid, not traded on an exchange or in an established market or for which no value can be readily determined, will be assigned such fair value as the investment manager may determine in its judgement based on various factors.
Such factors include, but are not limited to, aggregate dealer quotes or independent appraisals. Such valuations may not be indicative of what the actual fair market value would be in an active, liquid or established market.
(u) Investment strategies
Hedge funds are a relatively heterogeneous asset class in which the investment managers may determine their strategies in their sole discretion. As a consequence there is no commonly accepted definition for the strategies employed by hedge funds. It can even be impossible to associate certain hedge funds with only one specific definition of a strategy.
Furthermore there are various levels on which classifications can be made: any general strategy consists of various sub-strategies which may be very different from each other.
Financial Instruments may be linked to or be futures or options or issued as “over the counter” or bilateral contracts for which there is no trading market.